I was thinking about a solid plot-line for this game, and all the sudden, I just thought of this.
The main character (currently unnamed) is a gangster, stealing stuff in NYC. He and his gang work closely together, and have committed lots of crimes. But it is all about to change
A man, who says that he is a drug dealer, and wants to make a big offer for the gang, says he needs some help. He wants the gang to meet at a rooftop at midnight
After that cut scene, you go into game-mode, where you basically have to navigate up to the rooftop.
You go into ANOTHER cut scene, where the man, and your gang are on the rooftop. All the sudden, the man pulls out a gun. You try to get your gun out, but you can't reach to it in time. He shoots 2 of your gang members. You all run, but only you don't make it to the exit in time. The man pushes you to the edge of the rooftop, and you get pushed off. You fall, and fall, and fall, and hit the ground. Everything goes black.
You wake up (still in cut scene), and find yourself in complete blackness. You see a light, and you walk up to it. It blinds you, and you go into game-mode.
You are in a forest. Alone. (creepy music plays) You begin to walk, and explore your surroundings. Then some sort of monster (Not sure what yet) rushes in and attacks you. You pull out your gun, and fire a shot. It does nothing but anger the creature. You will need to find another way to kill it
That's all I have so far, may edit some good ideas or things I think of later